A silhouette of a wolf against an orange and yellow sunset. What better and thought-provoking image for a review  of George Monbiot's Feral?

A Review of George Monbiot's Feral

Feral: Rewilding the Land, Sea and Human Life, by George Monbiot

A silhouette of a wolf against an orange and yellow sunset. What better and thought-provoking image for a review  of George Monbiot's Feral?

A Review of George Monbiot's Feral

  • “Environmentalism in the twentieth century foresaw a silent spring, in which the further degradation of the biosphere seemed inevitable. Rewilding offers the hope of a raucous summer, in which, in some parts of the world at least, destructive processes are thrown into reverse.” George Monbiot's Feral provides an in-depth exploration into the state of our natural world. It is well informed, thought-provoking and, at times, controversial. It provides a broad overview for anyone wanting to learn more about the state of our planet’s ecosystems, why it’s so important to restore and rewild, and what is being done to make a positive change for our planet.

1. The Story

2. Rewilding or Conservation?

3. Positive Environmentalism

4. Ecological Boredom

5. A Look to the Future

  • “Environmentalism in the twentieth century foresaw a silent spring, in which the further degradation of the biosphere seemed inevitable. Rewilding offers the hope of a raucous summer, in which, in some parts of the world at least, destructive processes are thrown into reverse.” George Monbiot's Feral provides an in-depth exploration into the state of our natural world. It is well informed, thought-provoking and, at times, controversial. It provides a broad overview for anyone wanting to learn more about the state of our planet’s ecosystems, why it’s so important to restore and rewild, and what is being done to make a positive change for our planet.

1. The Story

2. Rewilding or Conservation?

3. Positive Environmentalism

4. Ecological Boredom

5. A Look to the Future

The Story

  • Feral invites you into a wilder world as envisioned by George Monbiot, a Guardian columnist, author and campaigner. It makes the case for a wilder, richer natural world in which we too are living wilder, more passionate lives. Throughout the book, this argument is brought to life by lyrical prose of Monbiot's own experiences of living in mining camps in the Brazilian rainforest and with the Masai in Kenya as well as both positive and negative examples of how we’ve altered our natural world. Focusing on Europe and, in particular, the UK, Feral has sparked discussion and excitement and ultimately led to the foundation of Rewilding Britain, a charity working at the forefront of British rewilding.

A lush green rainforest shrouded in mist
An old lone tree stands against an open landscape of green mountains in Scotland. Just many of the ecologically depleted areas discussed in George Monbiot's Feral.

Rewilding or Conservation?

  • Rewilding is the restoration of significant areas of land (and sea) in which natural processes are left to shape ecosystems on their own, without human interference. The goal of rewilding is not to reach a predetermined endpoint or ideal ecosystem. Monbiot contrasts this with the traditional conservation approach, which, according to him, simply keeps the land in a state of heavily managed degradation. He argues that this is partly because we have a false idea of what nature should look like, one that is based on a memory of what these habitats were like in our youth (‘shifting baseline syndrome').

The Story

  • Feral invites you into a wilder world as envisioned by George Monbiot, a Guardian columnist, author and campaigner. It makes the case for a wilder, richer natural world in which we too are living wilder, more passionate lives. Throughout the book, this argument is brought to life by lyrical prose of Monbiot's own experiences of living in mining camps in the Brazilian rainforest and with the Masai in Kenya as well as both positive and negative examples of how we’ve altered our natural world. Focusing on Europe and, in particular, the UK, Feral has sparked discussion and excitement and ultimately led to the foundation of Rewilding Britain, a charity working at the forefront of British rewilding.
A lush green rainforest shrouded in mist

Rewilding or Conservation?

Rewilding is the restoration of significant areas of land (and sea) in which natural processes are left to shape ecosystems on their own, without human interference. The goal of rewilding is not to reach a predetermined endpoint or ideal ecosystem. Monbiot contrasts this with the traditional conservation approach, which, according to him, simply keeps the land in a state of heavily managed degradation. He argues that this is partly because we have a false idea of what nature should look like, one that is based on a memory of what these habitats were like in our youth (‘shifting baseline syndrome').

An old lone tree stands against an open landscape of green mountains in Scotland. Just many of the ecologically depleted areas discussed in George Monbiot's Feral.

Ecological Boredom

  1. Monbiot presents numerous examples of how we have decimated ecosystems across the globe. He comes across a "pocket of canopied jungle" near his home in Wales, a remnant of the once thriving Atlantic rainforest, now a treeless desert. But Feral is, above all, a work of hope, one that aims to promote a positive kind of environmentalism. Monbiot presents his vision in the context of major rewilding initiatives. Reading these stories, we’re filled with a sense of hope and wonder at what could be. He talks about the ambitious work being carried out in Scotland and the positive ecological changes brought about in Yellowstone by the reintroduction of wolves.

Positive Environmentalism

    1. Monbiot presents numerous examples of how we have decimated ecosystems across the globe. He comes across a "pocket of canopied jungle" near his home in Wales, a remnant of the once thriving Atlantic rainforest, now a treeless desert. But Feral is, above all, a work of hope, one that aims to promote a positive kind of environmentalism. Monbiot presents his vision in the context of major rewilding initiatives. Reading these stories, we’re filled with a sense of hope and wonder at what could be. He talks about the ambitious work being carried out in Scotland and the positive ecological changes brought about in Yellowstone by the reintroduction of wolves.
A remnant of the once thriving Atlantic rainforest on a snowy day, and as what George Monbiot describes as a pocket of canopied jungle in his book Feral.
A black cat perches on a moss covered stone  in a wild garden

Ecological Boredom

One of the more unusual ideas in the book is the concept of 'ecological boredom'. Monbiot argues that, since many of us are isolated from the excitement and danger of the wild, we aren’t challenged in ways that require us to use the emotions and instincts that were integral to keeping us alive during our evolution. He cites the number of sightings of big cats in the UK as evidence. “As our lives have become tamer and more predictable, as the abundance and diversity of nature have declined, as our physical challenges have diminished to the point at which the greatest trial of strength and ingenuity we face is opening a badly designed packet of nuts, could these imaginary creatures have brought us something we miss?”. One of the benefits of rewilding, according to Monbiot, is the opportunity to step back into a world that is raw, exciting and thrilling.

One of the more unusual ideas in the book is the concept of 'ecological boredom'. Monbiot argues that, since many of us are isolated from the excitement and danger of the wild, we aren’t challenged in ways that require us to use the emotions and instincts that were integral to keeping us alive during our evolution. He cites the number of sightings of big cats in the UK as evidence. “As our lives have become tamer and more predictable, as the abundance and diversity of nature have declined, as our physical challenges have diminished to the point at which the greatest trial of strength and ingenuity we face is opening a badly designed packet of nuts, could these imaginary creatures have brought us something we miss?”. One of the benefits of rewilding, according to Monbiot, is the opportunity to step back into a world that is raw, exciting and thrilling.

A black cat perches on a moss covered stone  in a wild garden

A Look to the Future

  1. A review of George's Monbiot's Feral does not come without controversy, not least because rewilding itself is a controversial topic. Perhaps the biggest issue many have with Feral is that its emotive language regarding farming and other land use could alienate important stakeholders who are integral to the success of the rewilding movement. Nevertheless, Feral makes a thought-provoking and emotive case for rewilding that is sure to get people thinking differently and asking questions about our relationship with the natural world. It leaves you with a sense of wonder at the possibility of a world in which nature is left to take care of itself.
Trees stretch along the length of a valley overlooked by tall mountains
Trees stretch along the length of a valley overlooked by tall mountains

A Look to the Future

  1. A review of George Monbiot's Feral does not come without controversy, not least because rewilding itself is a controversial topic. Perhaps the biggest issue many have with Feral is that its emotive language regarding farming and other land use could alienate important stakeholders who are integral to the success of the rewilding movement. Nevertheless, Feral makes a thought-provoking and emotive case for rewilding that is sure to get people thinking differently and asking questions about our relationship with the natural world. It leaves you with a sense of wonder at the possibility of a world in which nature is left to take care of itself.

Sources & further reading

  1. ✅ for peer reviewed research
  2.  
  3. 1. “Feral: Searching for Enchantment on the Frontiers of Rewilding”– George Monbiot 2013 - penguin.co.uk
  4.  
  5. 2. “Opinion: Our Ecological Boredom” – The New York Times 2015 – nytimes.com
  6.  
  7. 3. “Rewilding European Landscapes” – Henrique Pereira and Laetitia Navarro 2015 –springer.com
  8.  
  9. 4. “A Manifesto for Rewilding the World” – George Monbiot 2013 – monbiot.com
  10.  
  11. 5. “Saving the World Should be Based on Promise, Not Fear” – George Monbiot 2014 – theguardian.com
  12.  
  13. 6. “Proving the ‘Shifting Baselines’ Theory: How Humans Consistently Misperceive Nature” – Jeremy Hance 2009 – mongabay.com
  14.  
  15. 7. “A Review of George Monbiot’s Feral” – Tony Whitbread 2014 – sussexwildlifetrust.org
  1. ✅ for peer reviewed research
  2.  
  3. 1. “Feral: Searching for Enchantment on the Frontiers of Rewilding”– George Monbiot 2013 - penguin.co.uk
  4.  
  5. 2. “Opinion: Our Ecological Boredom” – The New York Times 2015 – nytimes.com
  6.  
  7. 3. “Rewilding European Landscapes” – Henrique Pereira and Laetitia Navarro 2015 –springer.com
  8.  
  9. 4. “A Manifesto for Rewilding the World” – George Monbiot 2013 – monbiot.com
  10.  
  11. 5. “Saving the World Should be Based on Promise, Not Fear” – George Monbiot 2014 – theguardian.com
  12.  
  13. 6. “Proving the ‘Shifting Baselines’ Theory: How Humans Consistently Misperceive Nature” – Jeremy Hance 2009 – mongabay.com
  14.  
  15. 7. “A Review of George Monbiot’s Feral” – Tony Whitbread 2014 – sussexwildlifetrust.org
  16.  
  17.